Asphalt vs Metal Roof: Which Is Better? 

Asphalt VS Metal Roof Which Is Way Better

When you think it’s about time to install a new roof, you come with many available options to consider. Asphalt shingles are one of the most popular types of roofs that most homeowners prefer these days. These shingles are known for their ease of maintenance, reliability, and cost-effectiveness, making them very popular on the market today. 

However, metal roofing has gained popularity these days too and deserves great consideration too. That’s why people are stuck in the middle about what they should choose for roofing. That’s why in this article, you will know more about asphalt vs metal roofs and discover which works best for you. 

Which Is Better: Asphalt Or Metal Roof?

Perhaps you’re torn between choosing which is way better for your roof. In this battle, asphalt vs metal roof, here are some of the important things you need to know and understand regarding both. 

Understanding Asphalt Roof 

Asphalt shingle roofs are common and what you most likely see on residential homes today. The shingles that make it are the asphalt shingles because it is coated in asphalt to make it more resistant to moisture. It has a base material that is often fiberglass or organic fiber, coated or saturated in asphalt. 

One reason why asphalt shingles are very popular is due to their size, color, and shape, which come in a wide variety. Asphalt roof also comes with 3 asphalt shingle types, the 3-tab, luxury, and dimensional. To know more about these types, read down below: 

  • 3 – Tab Shingles 

The most common type of roofing you see nowadays. These are very affordable and could last a couple of decades, especially if it’s in the right condition.

  • Dimensional Shingles 

The dimensional asphalt shingles will always give you a good-looking pattern, even if it’s random. It features the look of a wood shake roof. These are also architectural or laminated shingles that feature two layers of shingles bonded together. Also, the bottom layer is exposed due to notches that were randomly removed from the shingle. 

Furthermore, the durability of dimensional shingles is one of the reasons why it’s popular. It boasts a multi-dimensional appearance and texture that can last more than 30 years. 

  • Luxury Shingles 

Luxury shingles are known to many as premium asphalt that is larger than any other asphalt shingles. It features a multi-dimensional appearance designed to be like cedar shake roofs and natural slate that will commensurate the cost. Luxury shingles are a reliable roofing alternative for homes in period style. It also creates a shadow and depth that looks just like a real slate or shakes. 

Common Benefits of Asphalt Roofing 

Perhaps you consider Asphalt roofs for your home. To help you develop the right decision, here are some of the advantages of opting for Asphalt roofs. 

  • Economical 

Asphalt Roofing is by far, one of the most affordable ways to replace roofing. It’s cheaper and upfront, as you may recoup some of the costs of a metal roof in the long run. It gives you many pricing options without compromising the value. In addition, the Asphalt shingles price will give you a lifespan of about 20 years and more. 

  • Easier to Repair and Install 

Asphalt shingles tend to be fast and easy to install and repair. It only requires a basic and little specialized knowledge. It can be installed right away, perhaps a day or two in most cases. Sometimes it could get finished ahead of time. 

There is always a huge advantage for people who avoid going home where construction is ongoing. Furthermore, the job is more precise, and there is less room for error; that’s why many workers could finish constructing an asphalt shingle roof in just a day. 

  • Comes with Different Color Option 

Asphalt shingles offer a wide variety of colors and styles that other roofing materials don’t offer. If you need to maintain your home’s appearance or enhance it, you have to pick the appropriate shade of roofing material that works best with the rest of your house. It comes in handy when the house owner will go for a specific look that compliments the home’s siding. 

  • Protection against Elements 

Asphalt shingles always protect against elements like water, heat, cold, ice, and even UV rays. It can also withstand strong winds for years to prevent water leakage. Furthermore, asphalt shingles are fire-resistant in a natural way. 

Drawbacks Of Asphalt Shingles 

Though asphalt shingles may seem like winning roofing material, it is still important to know some of the drawbacks. 

  • Requires periodic inspection 

Since maintenance is very limited, installing an asphalt shingle roof will require periodic inspections. It may also require occasional maintenance. 

  • It may be affected by heavy winds 

Since asphalt shingles overlap to always provide extra protection, it’s also possible for heavy winds to get underneath the shingles. However, asphalt shingles are made to last up to 110-mph winds beyond the extreme tornadoes and storms, but you still need to watch out for strong winds. 

Understanding Metal Roof 

A metal roof is simply defined as a roofing system made from metal pieces, panels, or tiles. It’s the 2nd common roof after asphalt, and it comes with two types of metal roof: the screw-down panels and standing-seam. 

The standing seam roof system comes with a series of metal panels that are locked and joined together at the seam mechanically. It also allows metal panels to expand and freely contract when metals heat up. 

On the other hand, the screw-down panel means it’s just screwed down. This is because the screws were screwed along with the metal panel, which leaves no room for contraction and expansion. 

It’s a part of a roofing system that works as a physical separator of both inside and outside the building. It is designed to always provide resistance and protection to water, air, heat, and sound. It also provides support to the structure and the overall aesthetic appearance of the building. 

Common Benefits Of Metal Roofing 

To help you decide if you will go for metal roofing, here are the benefits that you need to consider. 

  • Long-lasting 

Since it’s made of metals, a quality metal roof could last between 40 to 50 years, especially when properly installed. In addition, it seals out water, survives strong winds, and is resistant to fire. 

  • Lightweight 

One of the best things about metal roofing is its lightweight features. It weighs from 1 to 3 pounds each square foot, and it varies on the thickness and the kind of material. As a result, it’s one of the lightest of all roofing types, and even if it’s light in nature, it still serves its purpose and remains sturdy for the years to come. 

  • Serves as a Reflective Solar Coating 

Aside from the longevity and lightweight features, metal roofing also works as a reflective coating to minimize the building up of heat and to reduce air conditioning costs. It also helps you save electricity since you don’t always need to turn the AC on during warm sunny days. 

What Are The Disadvantages Of A Metal Roof? 

Before deciding to have metal roofing for your home, here are the possible drawbacks you need to consider. 

  • It creates noisy sounds 

You should know that a metal roof could be noisy, especially if it’s beneath a tile roof or thick slate during hailstorms and rainstorms. However, the idea of noise may vary on the construction. It can be controlled and prevented if you use quality materials. 

  • Prone to dents 

You should be open to the possibility that metal roofing will leave a dent. When there is heavy hail, there’s a big chance that your roof could get dents most especially if the roof is made of a soft metal like aluminum or copper. 

Asphalt VS Metal Roof: 4 Comparisons 

Now that you know and understand asphalt and metal roofs, here are the comparisons you should know to learn how they match key factors. 

  • Cost 

When it comes to the cost, asphalt roofs tend to be more affordable than metal roofs. However, you should know that metal panels cost more than asphalt shingles. It also requires you to hire skilled and professional laborers. 

  • Lifespan 

A roof’s lifespan could last for years, and it’s guaranteed to last when properly installed and built. If the roof is installed well and properly ventilated, it could get as much as possible to the specified lifespan. Having said that, the metal roof lasts longer than the asphalt roof. While an asphalt roof could last up to 40 years, the metal roof could last 50 years or more. 

  • Warranty Options 

Among the two, the asphalt roof comes with a better warranty option from the manufacturer. You can also enhance the warranty that covers the roof for up to 50 years. At the same time, metal roofs don’t always give much of an opportunity to have an enhanced warranty. Yes, it comes with a 30-year paint that could cover the coating, but it’s not as good as the asphalt roofs. 

  • Maintenance 

When it comes to maintenance, the asphalt needs inspection and maintenance at least once a year. The metal roof requires no maintenance at all, especially with a standing seam metal roof. However, it doesn’t mean that a metal roof shouldn’t be inspected because it still needs to prevent future problems. 


That wraps up the asphalt vs metal roof battle. Whether you go for asphalt or metal roofs, both of these still serve their purpose, and that is to protect you and your home from the elements. You just have to choose which one works for you while considering the factors that will help you in decision-making. 

I hope the guideline and key points have helped you decide on a better roofing system. In the end, it is always the functionality that counts and the protection it gives a home. 

Scroll to Top