Skip to Content

GAF vs. CertainTeed Roofing Shingles | Pros & Cons

gaf vs certainteed roofing shingles

In this post, we’ll compare the top two brands of roofing shingles: GAF vs. CertainTeed Roofing Shingles.

There are a number of reasons why homeowners might want to purchase one brand over the other, including price, warranties, and company reputation.

GAF and CertainTeed are two of the most well-known roofing companies in America. This comparison will help you compare their features, pros/cons, cost efficiency ratio as well warranties that come with each one for your convenience! 

CertainTeed is a leader in the home construction market, and they have many high-end products with some affordable lines.

One of the best parts about GAF is their variety. You can get whatever product you need for your home, from affordable shingle lines to high-end products that won’t break the bank!

Let’s take a closer look at each brand to see how they stack up against one another!

GAF vs. CertainTeed Roofing Shingles

CertainTeed is the premier manufacturer of exterior building materials and has won many awards.

The company has been making a variety of products to suit everyone’s needs. After seeing the success with their higher end line, CertainTeed made less expensive ones too like Landmark Series which are designed for those on a budget.

GAF’s roofing material manufacturing is world class and they have a variety of high-quality options to choose from too!

It is no surprise that certainTeed has been dominating the roofing industry for years.

While competition continues to increase, its dominance of this category shows how good it really was back when they first started out and what kind of company we can expect them to be in 10 or more years from now as well!

GAF is the No. 1 brand in most of these improved niches, with its products being cost-conscious and competitive against similar brands like Owens Corning, IKO.

GAF vs. CertainTeed Reliability and Quality

The debate between Certainteed and GAF shingles is an important one, with many aspects to consider. This comparison can help you make the best decision based on what is most important to you.

The bottom line is that both of these companies are great choices for roofing materials, and they have a wide range of price points to suit all budgets!

CertainTeed has been around since 1902 while GAF dates back to 1886 making them older than many other popular brands. Both companies have been well-established in the industry for decades and continue to be leaders!

Which one is right for you? The answer may depend on what your needs are, how much money you want to spend, or even which brand has better warranties!

It’s not just about style anymore. It is now more important than ever to focus on quality, and many homeowners know this all too well.

The first thing you should know about shingles is that they come in a variety of different materials.

For example, the kind I have on my roof right now are called “tin” or asphalt composition tiles and will last 15-25 years before becoming too worn out for anything other than repairing small patches with new pieces applied by an experienced professional who knows what he’s doing!


The GAF fiberglass-reinforced asphalt shingle is a great choice for homes in need of durable, long lasting coverage.

This product has been specifically designed to provide the best features from both wood and traditional styles with its 3 or 4 layers that overlap each other perfectly!

The most popular GAF shingles are the Timberline line, which weighs less than 240lbs per square. This is one reason why GAF warranties don’t last as long or cover as much.


CertainTeed’s asphalt shingles are made of a special material that is fiberglass-reinforced, making them stronger than other types.

There’s a reason why many homeowners choose CertainTeed for their roofing needs.

The company provides 4 or 5 layers of coverage, with some weighing up to 250lbs per square foot and having maximum heights around 450 inches tall even on the tallest models!

If you want your house to stand the test of time, it’s important that both weight and material matter.

Shingles like CertainTeed are more resistant than other brands in harsh weather conditions such as wind or hail impact while also not getting cupped or cracked when faced with these forces over long periods for years on end – they just keep looking good!

One downside to this is that very heavy roofing materials must be installed on steep roofs properly.

This can prevent sections from peeling off and potentially causing injury in an accident, so all your contractor needs are precautionary measures when it comes time for installation!

What’s Common CertainTeed and GAF

GAF’s and CertainTeed’s best shingles have a wind rating of 110MPH.

If you want to install them correctly, their warranties will be higher top – up to 130 MPH with enhanced installation practices including extra nails matching starter strips or caps for an even better protection against high-speed winds!

They are exactly what you need for your next project. The steel has the same ASTM certification as other materials, making it an excellent option in terms of safety and durability!

GAF has been a best-selling shingle brand because it makes quality products.

CertainTeed is also the leader in premium categories, such as siding and windows, with strong focus on making outstanding high-end items for those looking to distinguish themselves from their neighbors or competitors

In addition to these, both companies have been so successful across all markets that they own most if not all top tier niches within construction materials like: roofing; gutters & downspouts; decking boards and more!

Comparing Cost of GAF and CertainTeed Roofing Shingles

The average price of CertainTeed shingles is higher than the cost for GAF products, though not as high 10 years ago.

CertainTeed’s new pricing strategy is an attempt to get more of the market, and they know that if you’re on a budget there are plenty who will buy their products.

GAF shingles are available wherever roofing materials can be found, which means they’re sometimes even sold at Lowe’s and Home Depot.

CertainTeed has a history of selling their products through wholesalers.

They have partnered with companies like Beacon Supply, Harvey’s Industries and ABC Supply that specialize in roofing supply to professionals across America who work as contractors for residential homes or businesses alike!

There are a few wholesalers like Reese in Indiana that also sell to the public.

Here are the current sample prices to compare CertainTeed Roofing Shingles and GAF. All of these deals come with a 100 sq ft minimum purchase, so you can find out which one is best for your home! 

Basic 3-Tab Shingles

The GAF Royal Sovereign costs between $62-$78, the CertainTeed XT25 is about 70%-85 dollars depending on how many layers you have installed.

Premium Designer shingles

You can’t go wrong with an energy-efficient roof. GAF Woodland shingles are $170-$194, CertainTeed Highland Slate is at $200 and up for the Grand Manor variety!

Best architectural shingles (dimensional)

The GAF Timberline Ultra HD/HDZ is a high-quality product that costs less than $150. It has been described by customers as “extremely durable,” and can withstand heavy snow loads with no problem!

The Landmark Premium from CertainTeed will work well for people who want an elegant design on their home without breaking down every winter season or costing more money, while Independence Shingles come in at around 180 dollars but offer excellent protection against hail storms which may occur during your lifetime.”

Good/Better Architectural shingles (dimensional)

The GAF Timberline HD/HDZ and CertainTeed Landmark are two of the most popular brands for siding.

The prices can vary depending on what you want, but a good rule is to expect about $85-$100 from one company or another when comparing them side by-side! The CertainTeed Landmark PRO is at $120-$130.

With so many different brands to choose from, consumers are always looking for the best deal. They will often go with GAF if given an estimate on comparable products and prices before making their decision.

Selection of Shingle Style

You’ll be able to find several good-looking options that fit your home’s architecture, style and setting. Shingles are a beautiful way to cover your home.

There’s more than one brand, so you’ll be able to find the perfect shingle for any style and setting that fits what you’re looking for in no time at all!

Both brands have an excellent selection of shingles, so finding several good-looking options to fit your home’s architecture style and setting will not be hard. You can choose from different styles including:

GAF Woodland Shingles, GAF Royal Sovereign and Grand Manor; CertainTeed Landmark Premium shingles both in regular and Victorian designs.

Which is Better? GAF vs. CertainTeed Roofing Shingles

CertainTeed Shingle Styles

It can be difficult to find a roof that suits your needs. Fortunately, CertainTeed has you covered with their wide variety of shingle styles and color options available!

Grand Manor

CertainTeed’s Grand Manor has a variety of colors that are sure to suit your tastes. The thick, randomly cut slate-style shingles come in 10 different shades and 425lbs/square for high-contrast coverage against sun damage on homes across America!

Carriage House

Three-sided, traditionally designed slate-like edges with contrasting upper and lower layers in 8 hues that are 355lbs/square are found on the Treetop Carriage House from Three Simple Secrets.

Arcadia Shake

This new Arcadia Shake from CertainTeed is made with rustic split wood shake-look in six colors, four layers of it.


CertainTeed’s Independence has a variety of colors to choose from, with 9 Premium architectural shingle designs.


The Northgate Premium Shake-style Shingles with top-rated Class 4 impact resistance and flexibility for cold weather installation is a great option to consider.

In 10 colors, these shingles provide you the ability to create just about any design or color scheme imaginable without having it fade due time!

Highland Slate

CertainTeed’s Highland Slate has Wide-cut, slate-look shingles in 8 colors. If you’re looking for an affordable and stylish product to give your home that historic feel without breaking the bank then these are perfect!


The CertainTeed Patriot has a strip of color rather than the typical dimensional shingles. This house not only looks great on its own, but it also makes an architectural statement within any industry or neighborhood!

GAF Shingle Styles

GAF is the largest manufacturer of residential shingles. With their large selection, you’re guaranteed to find what your home needs!

GAF Timberline Architectural Shingles

GAF’s Timberline Architectural Shingles come in a variety of colors, giving you more options than ever before.

The HDZ Reflector frame is a classically styled ultra-high definition model that meets the latest standards for CA Title 24, LA County requirements. With its rich and vibrant colors it will be sure to impress you with every view from your windows!

The Natural Shadow series of asphalt shingles is a low-maintenance way to add an element of natural beauty and curb appeal while staying cool in the summertime.

The Cool Series specializes in energy star certified products, making them perfect for those who care about sustainable living!

GAF Lifetime Designer Shingles

For those looking for high-end products, GAF is where it’s at.

  • GAF has the perfect rustic-style shingles for your home! With their Grand Canyon key cut, these shake roofs are sure to get you curb appeal.
  • The GAF brand has an impressive line of slate-look shingles in elegant designs.
  • GAF’s Glenwood triple-layer wood shake shingle is a perfect fit for your home.
    • It has an authentic, traditional look that will enhance the natural beauty of any exterior while adding protection from water and wind damage on ceilings in inclement weather conditions.

GAF Value Designer Shingles

These affordable dimensional shingles are the perfect choice for people who want to stay in their house for 20-30 years.

  • GAF has the Camelot II – like a more economical, lighter version of its original.
  • GAF’s Sienna old-fashioned style shingles are a beautiful, yet durable option for any home.
  • The product comes with a lifetime warranty and is made out of tough material that will last you through many years without showing any signs of wear.

GAF Three-tab Shingles

The GAF ratings for a variety of different building materials suggest that these projects will require basic protection.

  • The classic design of GAF’s 30-year Marquis WeatherMax shingles will look great on your home.
  • GAF has the top-of-the line 25 year Royal Sovereign shingles.

Price Comparison for New Roofs

When it comes to roof replacement costs, you’ll be able to find several good deals that fit your budget.

The price range can vary depending on what you want, but a good rule is to expect about $85-$100 from one company or another when comparing them side by-side!

New roof prices for GAF and CertainTeed products will be around the same amount compared to each other.

Both brands offer at least three different types of shingles to choose from, so there are several good deals that fit your budget.

CertainTeed offers a 20-year limited warranty on their shingle products.

GAF also offers warranties varying in lengths of time depending on the product you purchase. Both brands have excellent customer service and stand behind all of their work!

Comparing Warranty of GAF and CertainTeed Roofing Shingles

A warranty is a guarantee that the manufacturer has confidence in their product. It’s important because it tells you what they think about themselves, but there are always some catches!

  • GAF and CertainTeed both have a range of warranties covering their various products.
    • They also offer quality assurance programs for your peace of mind, so you can get the most out of them while still being careful with what’s important!
  • Shingle warranties are notoriously difficult to work with.
    • They give out so many loopholes that it can be tough for homeowners trying to find somebody willing and able to fix their issue, let alone getting compensated on time!
  • GAF has more rigorous warranties than CertainTeed.
    • If you have a problem with your roof, GAF will not just replace it; they’ll fix or refund the cost of any work done on an older roof if there’s been significant degradation in its performance due to weathering.

All roofing manufacturers have a policy on warranty claims, and this leads to many denied applications.

To avoid the hassle of waiting ages for your claim to be processed or paying out an exorbitant amount in fees just because you didn’t follow proper installation techniques from start-to-finish, make sure that any installer working with materials handled by them has at least five years’ experience under their belt!

The best way to know you’re getting a good deal from your roofing contractor is by checking if they offer warranties. If not, then who will cover any installation issues?

The roofer should also make sure to check out the ventilation in your attic and on top of every deck. This can help you avoid issues from excess moisture and heat.

Making the right choice of roofing manufacturer will save you money and time, so make sure to do your research before deciding on a shingle.

GAF vs. CertainTeed are both reputable companies but have different warranties so it’s important to compare the options and choose what works best for you.

If you’re thinking about re-roofing your house and need help with deciding which type of shingle will best suit the needs, be sure to do your research.

Warranties vary between GAF and CertainTeed products, so it’s important to research what will work best for you.

GAF vs. CertainTeed Roofing Shingles GAF and CertainTeed both have a range of warranties covering their various products, but they vary in length depending on which shingle you purchase.

Both brands offer excellent customer service and stand behind all of their work!

What is the Best Choice? GAF vs. CertainTeed Roofing Shingles